Friday, May 11, 2012

Motherhood Under Attack

In this, the week where we honor and celebrate mothers and their contributions, the media is instead putting motherhood under attack. From a series of blogs in the New York Times to the front cover of Time Magazine, child-centered parenting and by association, motherhood, is under fire.

The unfolding stories about motherhood question whether feminism and motherhood are compatible or if mothers are doing "enough" or perhaps taking their parenting styles too far. The media is dividing mothers into camps - feminists vs. mothers, attached parents vs. empowered parents, parents who are "enough" and those who fall short of the mark. Mothers are either/or, up for public evaluation and criticism, or left hung out to dry. Fathers, ironically, do not engender such criticism. Being present is enough to simply qualify a dad as "good enough" - a little help around the home and he is to be celebrated. But for moms motherhood is a minefield.

If you listen to the media, following your instincts in parenting makes you a slave to your children. Ancients practices of breastfeeding, babywearing, and co-sleeping are exhausting and a likely manifestation of mothers trying to make up for their own inadequate childhoods. And all of it strips women of their independence, their power, and their choice. Lines are drawn in the sand. I am a good enough mother because I do this, you are not. I am a feminist and you are just a mother. You are a bad mother because you also have a career.

Motherhood is a universal experience. All mothers are exhausted. All mothers make sacrifices for their children, put some of their own desires on hold, and want to raise happy and healthy children. We all want to keep our children safe and protect them. We will stand by them and nurse them back to health when they sick. We will fight for them, move mountains for them, give every ounce of energy for them no matter what parenting model we follow.

Mothers who can make choices are empowered. Mothers who can choose to work or stay home, to co-sleep or babywear, to embrace their roles as mothers and as professionals, and to make informed, educated choices that work for them and their families are perhaps the most powerful force on the planet. And we are all mothers.

Let's not spend this Mother's Day pointing fingers and judging one another. Let's celebrate the joys and the challenges of motherhood that we all share. Let's honor the hard work, the passion, the dedication, the tolerance and patience, and the great love that all mothers share. Let us celebrate and honor the community of mothers, the universalities of our experience, and the enormous respect we have for one another's tasks. And let us acknowledge the power of our collective voices, our ability to honor one another, and our power to tolerate and respect our differences.

Happy Mother's Day!


  1. Yes! Well said!

  2. beautiful! THank you for this...this was much needed. Ive been feeling very enraged this week as well. I hadnt even realized that mothers day was just around the corner too!

  3. Great post. Thank you. It deeply saddens me that we have to so fiercely defend motherhood.

  4. Thank you for this article! Well said.

  5. I don't see it that way. I saw that article as another style to parenting. I think women who are getting their panties in a wad over the media bringing all this to the surface may have a lack of confidence. I don't attachment parent and I don't feel bad at all. My family is happy and healthy and that is all that matters to me. Good job for all the mom's who work, stay home, wear their kids, bottle feed, breast feed etc! ! We all have at least one thing in common, we love our children with every ounce of our being. Don't feel bad or threatened. Just keep on doing what you do:)

  6. Well said! I am so sick of mothers being the guinea pigs - we suffer from enough of our own guilt, thank you!
    I respectfully disagree that the Time article was just discussing "another style to parenting" - the title was something to the effect, "Are you mom enough" implying that by favouring one approach over another, you weren't doing enough. While I nursed my kids, I certainly know that it is not feasible or even possible for some women to breastfeed and they shouldn't have to be labelled as moms who didn't do 'enough'. Equally wrong is reactions/responses that suggest that attachment parenting (inc extended breastfeeding) is 'controversial' and the photographer responsible for the cover went as far as to say that he showed the child standing up to show how 'uncommon' nursing an older child was. It was intended to create a stir and it did.


Thank you for sharing your comments with us! Please note that direct solicitations, links for marketing purposes, and other self-promotions in our comments will be removed. Thank you for your cooperation.